CHAPTER 45: David Noel’s Accident, Confusing Church Mixups and Rabbits for Dinner
Ed. note: We are in the Fall of 1929. Pearl begins on a light note with the three young children and some touching happenings. Then, she follows with the heartbreaking story of a terrible accident that happens to David, the 18-year-old son of Grandma Noel, the youngest child of seven from the union of Jim and Amanda Jane Noel. In order of birth: Frank, Austin, Oma, Viola, Lona, Lavada and David. Then, we read of how Frank goes through some confusing church membership experiences. The year of 1930 arrives with large, record breaking snowfall for Oklahoma and the harbinger of the beginning of the Great Depression economic time. Thus, she ends with the humorous tale of rabbits. RAN
Learning To Talk, or Not
Calvin was three years old, and J.T. was only one year old when Mildred first went to school. Calvin had talked from his first year, just about, although one could not always understand him. J.T. would not even try to talk. He motioned to communicate with us, pointing to food or drink to show us what he wanted. In the Fall of 1929, 5-year-old Calvin talked constantly, full of questions, as most 5-year-olds are. But he struggled to speak Mildred’s name. He began somewhere back in his two-year-old “mumbo-jumbo” to call her “Bunh”. It did not sound like “fun”, rather it sounded more like “buh”. The expression had a nasal quality that was difficult to describe. Around this time, he decided to try saying “Mildred”. Mildred and I both tried repeatedly to lead him into speaking it. He came in the kitchen to me and announced, “I can say ‘Mildred’! I didn’t know that I could. See? ‘Mildred’!” That was a milestone in Calvin’s vocabulary development!
Ed. note: In this 1929 photo we find Calvin, 5, and Mildred, 8 up in the tree and J.T., standing in the foreground, is 3. Apologies for the poor quality of this 97 y.o. old photo. RAN
The 1929 cotton harvest burned up in the late, hot summer, so there were no funds to buy land in West Texas, which was a hope that had promised so much in the early summer. Again, the farmer’s hopes and dreams are blasted!
David’s Tragic Accident

Ed. note: The image above shows a “strip-down” Model T. So, David is driving something similar to this when the following tragic accident occurred. RAN
On November 28, 1929, a gun blast changed the life and plans of Frank’s younger brother, David, nearing 19 years of age. He was out hunting on the river, driving an old Model T “strip-down” with no mats on the floorboards. Kenneth Bailey, around seventeen, was riding with him, and David was driving with the loaded shotgun sitting beside him on his left side, the barrel pointing skyward. As they bumped along the road, full of chuck-holes, the gun slipped down into the slot in the floorboard. When the trigger of the gun hit the board, the gun discharged, sending the charge through David’s left elbow. David, stunned and numbed by the impact, didn’t realize what had happened for several seconds. The vehicle stopped; Kenneth, seeing what the gun blast had done, began running for help. He knew where Frank was plowing and ran more than a mile across the fields to him. He could have gone to two different neighbors, each one-half mile away, but stunned as he was, he couldn’t think of that. David, becoming faint at the car, climbed out and walked to the nearby creek and got into the water. Dousing his face with the cool water, which revived him somewhat, he walked on to the Dan Sutherland residence. The Sutherlands or the Smiths summoned Dr. Foshee. Possibly the Smiths, as a Smith came to our house, as David was brought there.
They carried him into our bedroom where Dr. Foshee soon arrived to examine him. His brief examination revealed that David needed the attention of a surgeon. Dr Foshee bandaged the wound as well as could be accomplished, with strips of old, clean sheets. Frank made a bed for him in the back seat of the car and sped him to the Frederick Hospital in Frederick, Oklahoma, for the services of Dr. Fisher. Meanwhile, Dr. Fisher was alerted that the gunshot victim was on his way there.
Upon the initial examination, Dr Fisher thought he might save the arm by performing an operation that would leave the elbow loose, leaving the arm of little use to David. This operation was not feasible, however, so he took the arm off, leaving as much of the bone as he could. He did not leave enough tissue and skin to cover the bone, which necessitated a second operation a while later, during which another length of bone was removed, and the tissue and skin were properly sutured to prevent any other physical problems. This time the arm healed nicely. Of course, there is always the emotional and psychological feature to deal with. I recall that David had a sensation that his hand was itching, and his mother wondered if ants were on the hand and arm, buried in the plots at Dunkard Cemetery, where his father and sister were buried. It was generally concluded that ants were unlikely to live as deep underground as the arm was buried. After the second operation relieved David of the pain he had suffered due to infection, he appeared to be happy to be at ease and thankful that the accident was no worse than it was.
The Benevolent, Kind Staley Family
In the winter and spring of 1930, J. A. Staley, an old friend and benefactor of the Noel family through the years, persuaded David and Frank to allow him to take David into his home to live and enroll in a public school in Wichita Falls, Texas. After much consideration, they decided to try it, as with only one arm for his life ahead of him, he did need more education. So, David moved into the Staley mansion with the family and enrolled in elementary education at some level. It wasn’t easy, as school, both books and discipline, were always difficult for David. He had discontinued his formal education upon moving to Carnegie, Oklahoma. He had not attained farther than the fifth or sixth grade at that time. He did attend classes for some weeks at the Wichita Falls school, but as I recall, at some point in the spring, March or April, David decided to call it “quits”. Mrs. Staley was so gracious to us all. He bought new clothes for David; I recall a beautiful gray flannel suit and other casual clothes. Moreover, at Easter, the Staleys invited us to attend Easter service on Sunday morning.
This Easter service was not in their church but at a pageant on the bare slopes of a shallow canyon near Wichita Falls. I had heard of the outdoor Easter Pageant; in fact, I had read about it in the Wichita Falls newspaper, and we were honored to be asked to attend the event with the Staleys. As we reached the amphitheater that cold, clear morning, I got my little brood of three out of the car and found our places to sit on a low bank, but high enough above the scene of the pageant for a good view. I had made spring clothes for the children that didn’t include any jackets or windbreakers against the chill of that Easter morning. J.T.’s little Pongee suit, with short sleeves and pants, was quite inadequate for outdoor wear, as I realized while we sat out and enjoyed the pageant. The Staleys were good hosts, pointing out some of the principal figures responsible for this magnificent production. The warm breakfast back at the Staleys was a welcome sight as we returned from the pageant. While we said our goodbyes and expressed our thanks for their hospitality, they were preparing to attend their Easter service at their church. As we began our trip back to Grandfield, Oklahoma, we realized that our humble home was truly “home sweet home” to us. In retrospect, I assume that David had experienced the same emotions many times. He could not accept the luxurious residence as his home, and moreover, he found himself pressured by the Staleys in spite of their grace and cordiality. Their intentions were pure, and J. A. Staley recalled his humble beginnings, having started out in life with only a fourth-grade education, speaking of it in David’s presence. Nevertheless, the transition was just too great a gulf for David to span.
David came back to our home, then to his sister Viola’s home a few miles from ours and then to another sister, Lona’s, up in Carnegie, where he seemed to spend much of his time in those years. He would help out on the farm as much as he could, as he began conditioning himself to making his way with only one arm.
Some Experiences with Church Membership
Ed. note: This narrative could be a bit confusing, as several churches are involved, which is Pearl’s point in the story. There is humor, but somewhat disconcerting discoveries for Frank regarding the important fact of belonging to more than one church. Also, there seemed to be some arcane rules about letters of transfer among the churches, which were not always followed closely. Geographically, from the Noel home, Pleasant Valley School, where many of the Noel children attended elementary school through 8th grade, a one-room school building, was a 1.5-mile walk. A group of Christians rented this building for Sunday worship in 1910 and called the church Pleasant Valley School Church. Pleasant Mound Baptist Church was 4 miles east and 0.5 miles north of the Noel farm home. This church is where I spent much of my childhood, as did my 6 older siblings. The Pleasant Valley church, in the mid 1920s, merged with Pleasant Mound, moving to the latter’s campus and using the name Pleasant Mound Baptist Church. RAN
Our family had turned over a new leaf that spring of 1930, a few weeks before Easter, by joining the Pleasant Mound Baptist Church, located some 5 miles east of our home. Frank and I were members at the Antioch Baptist Church, another country church some 9 miles west of us. Frank learned, however, while talking with the pastor of Pleasant Mound church, that the church had not lettered him out of that church to the Antioch Baptist, when he joined there on the promise of a letter some years before. Frank was a member, therefore, “in good standing” of Pleasant Mound Baptist Church, so only I would transfer my membership. Frank had become a member of the Pleasant Valley School Church in 1920 by baptism. Meanwhile, the Pleasant Valley School Church joined the fellowship of the Pleasant Mound Baptist Church, thereby combining the two churches.
An interesting, though bizarre, situation existed regarding Frank’s church membership. We recalled that, when I made a profession of faith at the Sanford Methodist Church in 1923, Frank and I both committed ourselves to membership there. This was without consideration of church doctrines or policies, because our hearts and attitudes seemed so closely intertwined with the fellowship there.

Ed. note: This photograph and description below are from a history of Tillman County: Sanford Methodist Church was built in 1923, 9 1/2 miles east and one mile south of Davidson. The church was built on two acres of land in the southeast corner of a quarter section belonging to a Kiowa Indian. Located on the crest of a hill, the church could be seen for miles in all directions. The location was chosen because it was in the approximate center of four school districts: Hackberry, Chateau, Rita, and Sanford. Previously, religious services had been held in the school buildings and pastored by minister-farmers in the area. RAN
I thought about it more seriously within the two weeks I was awaiting baptism; however, I reasoned that it might not be wise to become a Methodist, because the Baptist church was all I had ever known. Furthermore, I assumed that as I matured, being 18 years old at the time, I would likely lean towards the Baptist church teaching and finally move into the church of my upbringing. In such a case, why not correct the mistake now by joining the Antioch Baptist Church, which I did, at the baptismal waters’ edge before I had been baptized. But Frank was baptized at Sanford Methodist Church and remained a member there. That winter, living in Frederick in early 1924, we attended the Antioch Baptist Church on the promise some Sundays, on our way to visit Mandy or my folks, so one Sunday Frank joined Antioch church, on the promise of a letter from the Pleasant Valley School Church, where he joined in 1920 by baptism.

No one thought of notifying the Sanford Methodist Church of the change of religious persuasion at that time. But, one day in the winter of 1929-30, I believe, two young women visited our home and asked about our church attendance. They were from the Sanford Methodist Church, conducting a survey of the community to locate some of their members. To Frank’s consternation, they informed him that he was still a member of the Sanford Methodist Church. Then, when being informed in the spring of 1930 that he was a member of Antioch Baptist Church; well, I could not repeat his words, if I could recall what they were; they would be so profane! The meaning of what he said was this: “There I was, belonging to three churches at the same time and not attending any one of them!” Frank was not a regular church-goer at any time in his life except at revival time, about two weeks at a time. That’s the way he was brought up through his boyhood years, back in Texas, early in this (20th) century. On the other hand, church attendance was a fulfillment in my life; not only a fulfillment, but a joy and a desire for participation that grew as I became more mature in the years that followed.
Frank attended church quite regularly throughout the year 1930; we all did, I should say, because Frank enjoyed the pastor, Dan Green, who was just “an old farmer,” as he was, Frank remarked. He marveled at how well Dan handled the language, wondering how he had learned to read the Bible so well and to interpret its passages so skillfully. Summer brought busy, tiring days for Frank, the farmer, and he gradually began to drop out, telling me and the kids to go ahead. He would rest, look over the crops, or maybe a neighbor or two would come by and sit in the shade and visit until it was too late for him to go to church.
We had actually begun church attendance at Pleasant Mound Baptist Church, when Taylor Hill and family dropped by either in the fall of 1929 or in the early spring of 1930.Taylor had heard about Dan Green, a farmer-turned-preacher, and how well he proclaimed the gospel. He said to us, “Why don’t we all go over there to hear him preach tonight?” So, we did. I don’t recall whether they attended again, but it was a beginning for us.
.
Ed. note: This scene, just outside the Pleasant Mound Baptist Church, as the sign reads if you zoom it in, shows Pearl, far right, speaking with someone and shaking hands. The date was in the early to mid-1950s. Farm fields surrounded the church. There was a parsonage on the grounds. This is the church I grew up in most of my childhood through early teens (1940-1955). It is located 4 miles east of our farm home. We went twice on Sunday for worship and every Wednesday evening for prayer service. My father, Frank’s funeral was help here. A reminder: this church merged with Pleasant Valley School Church after 1920. RAN
Beginning of Economic Downturn and Eating Rabbits
Rainfall had been insufficient during 1930, so the fall, 1930, cotton crop was poor. Frank brought home some cotton sacks, and Frank and I picked the few bales of cotton on our place. Then we drove three miles to the Morton place, where Uncle Charley(the youngest of Pearl’s Thornton uncles) had moved, and we gathered a patch of cotton there, for one-half of it. Times were becoming hard for us, as farm products were selling for low prices, in addition to poor production. The infamous Stock Market Crash had occurred in October of 1929, but reverberations were just now beginning to be felt in the farm belt. With the exception of the heavy snowfall on the first of January, 1930, which remained on the ground for the entire month, moisture must have been negligible for the remainder of the year.

Ed. note: I grew on the farm with jack rabbits and cotton-tail rabbits as the most commonly sighted. These photos show an actual “cotton-tail” on this name-sake small mammal, which the Noels ate briefly in 1930. We rarely ate one in the 1950s, when a family member or friend hunted and killed too many. Tastes like “chicken” Never a favorite. RAN
That month, at the beginning of 1930, made history in our family. Lee Nash, Frank’s hired hand, who lived alone that winter in a shack on the farm, went out rabbit hunting every day. A sure kill was made each day as the cotton-tail rabbits could not hop so well in the deep snow. Lee caught too many rabbits for his own use, so he began bringing rabbits to us. He would have them skinned and dressed, ready to fry. They were quite like young chickens, ready to cook. We had never tasted rabbit before, and soon we had had enough. We let him bring them on, keeping them frozen in a north window box until Frank finally said it was enough! He amused the kids by repeating the old cowboy’s prayer!
“Lord, we’ve had rabbit young, we’ve had rabbit old; we’ve had rabbit hot, and we’ve had rabbit old; we’ve had rabbit tough. Dear Lord, don’t you think we’ve had rabbit enough?”
Rare Deep Snowfall and Family Visits
During the deep snow in January 1930, Lavada Noel, Frank’s youngest sister, and Frank Scott were married. Roads were impassable in some areas, but somehow they made it to see us and her big sister, Viola (Frank’s nearest sister in age and geography) and her husband, Ueal Bowman. They walked in, out of the snow, to our great surprise! We were happy to see them, but I thought it was an inopportune time, as I had the mumps. Yes, I had contracted it from the school kids, a sore throat from tonsillitis, and a boil on my arm! But we made it through!

Also, that January, toward the end of the month, when it was clearing and thawing, my brother, Billy, and his wife, Verly, came by while preparing to move up to Carnegie to farm Austin’s land. They had married a year before, having lived in the Thornton’s first little house on the farmstead. Billy considered this a good move; perhaps, he would do better up there in Carnegie than if he stayed in Tillman County farming. I’m sure it proved out to be dry in that area, too.
Ed. note: We look forward to some enjoyable, lighter reading in Chapter 46, with children’s antics and a good crop, along with learning to pressure-cook vegetables grown in the garden. Stay tuned. RAN










































































